diff --git a/docs/components.md b/docs/components.md index 5ac7501..33bbb79 100644 --- a/docs/components.md +++ b/docs/components.md @@ -39,6 +39,13 @@ Components 1xVoice Reciever - Round screen thingy 1xSound System +##Lighting + +~16x RGB smart bulb (exact count/room split TBD — see #Open items). Zigbee, not +WiFi, to match this project's existing local-first Zigbee2MQTT backbone (already +have the coordinator dongle) rather than adding a second, cloud-dependent lighting +ecosystem. See #Need for the specific pick and why. + ##Summed totals #Servers @@ -56,6 +63,9 @@ Components 1x Tiny PC with Mini Touchscreen (Kitchen) 1x Camera (Kitchen) +#Lighting +~16x RGB smart bulb (Zigbee) — count/room split not finalized + #By room Living Room: 1x ThinClient, 1x Voice Reciever, 1x Sound System (have) Loggia: 1x Miniscreen System (have), 1x Sound System, 1x Voice Reciever @@ -65,6 +75,8 @@ Kitchen: 1x Tiny PC w/ Touchscreen, 1x Camera, 1x Voice Reciever, 1x Sound #Open items - Linus Room's "???" line is still undecided. +- Bulb count/room split is a guess ("like 16") — not yet mapped to specific rooms + or fixture counts per room. #Have 1xSound System (earmarked for Living Room) @@ -137,6 +149,28 @@ are not: (see link for price) — any UVC webcam works; picked for wide availability/driver support, not a specific requirement +#Lighting — need ~16 RGB smart bulbs (count TBD) +**Zigbee, not WiFi/cloud bulbs** — the whole point of the Zigbee2MQTT backbone this +project already runs (§1.3) is one local mesh instead of N different manufacturer +clouds; a WiFi bulb (Tuya/WiZ/etc.) would be a second, cloud-dependent ecosystem +bolted onto a stack that's explicitly local-first everywhere else. Mains-powered +Zigbee bulbs also act as mesh **routers**, which matters here specifically: ~16 of +them spread across every room does more for whole-house Zigbee coverage (for the +battery sensors in §1.4) than the coordinator alone ever could. + +Three real options were compared, not just the first search hit: + +| Option | Router? | Zigbee2MQTT support | Price | Verdict | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| [innr RB 285 C](https://www.amazon.de/Smart-dimmbar-kompatibel-Philips-RB/dp/B07GT1LWDH) (also [2-pack](https://www.amazon.co.uk/Innr-Colour-Philips-Assistant-Required/dp/B07GT12JTJ)) | Yes | Confirmed — [zigbee2mqtt.io device page](https://zigbee.blakadder.com/Innr_RB_285_C.html) | ~€15–20/bulb (docs/project-plan.md §1.4) | **Picked** — already this project's own documented choice, real listings on multiple Amazon EU sites, RGBW + tunable white 2200–6500K | +| IKEA TRÅDFRI color | Yes | Well-supported, huge install base | ~€12–15/bulb (cheapest of the three) | Not on Amazon in most regions (IKEA.com/stores only) — cheaper on paper but doesn't fit "find it on Amazon," and the color-capable SKU specifically (not the tunable-white-only ones) needs care to pick | +| Sengled Zigbee color (e.g. [2-pack](https://www.amazon.com/Sengled-Changing-Dimmable-Multicolor-Equivalent/dp/B0899LJHVV)) | **No** — end device only | Supported, but community reports of RGB/XY color quirks on some zigbee2mqtt versions | Similar ballpark to innr | Skipped — buying 16 non-router bulbs throws away the mesh-strengthening benefit that's the actual reason to prefer mains-powered bulbs here | + +Buying at this quantity: check amazon.de for a 4-pack or larger multi-pack of the +RB 285 C (cheaper per-unit than 16x single-packs) before ordering singles. + +4x-pack pricing wasn't found in search results — verify against the live listing. + #Open items carried over from above - Linus Room's "???" line is still a completely open slot — nothing to shop for until it's decided what it is. @@ -146,6 +180,8 @@ are not: it properly — see that host's README "Touch input: two tiers"), so this is no longer a go/no-go check, just worth running once to know which tier it landed in and whether the override needs filling in for full multi-touch. +- Bulb count/room split — priced below at ~16, but that's a placeholder pending an + actual per-room fixture count. ##Price estimate @@ -171,11 +207,14 @@ local pricing/VAT/shipping. | 16AWG speaker wire, 100ft spool *(one-time)* | 1 | €15–22 | €15–22 | | 10.3" portable USB-C touchscreen monitor | 1 | €85–130 | €85–130 | | Logitech HD Pro Webcam C920 | 1 | €55–75 | €55–75 | +| innr RB 285 C Zigbee RGB bulb | ~16 (TBD) | €15–20 | €240–320 | -**Subtotal (excludes the optional beamer mount): ~€1,489–1,700** -**Subtotal, including the optional beamer mount: ~€1,504–1,725** +**Subtotal (excludes the optional beamer mount): ~€1,729–2,020** +**Subtotal, including the optional beamer mount: ~€1,744–2,045** All 5 Sound Systems (Living Room, Loggia, Linus Room, Amirs Room, Kitchen) are confirmed — see `#Open items` above — so all 4 needed amp+speaker kits are in the -main table above. Linus Room's still-blank "???" line isn't priced at all — there's -nothing to estimate until it's decided what it is. +main table above. The bulb line is the least certain figure in this whole table — +16 is a round-number placeholder, not a counted fixture list, so treat that +€240–320 as the roughest estimate here. Linus Room's still-blank "???" line isn't +priced at all — there's nothing to estimate until it's decided what it is.